The Bay Cafe Restaurant

Welcome to The Bay Cafe & Restaurant

Bay Cafe and Restaurant is a unique style restaurant as our menu changes seasonally. We are focused on giving our guests the freshest gourmet dishes by our talented trained chefs. 

We are across the street from the Bay serving lunch, dinner and brunch on Sundays. The Bay Cafe and restaurant are perfect for family dining, dates and post dates. Experience our warm hospitality from the moment you enter our doors. Enjoy our elaborate gourmet pastas, fish and don’t miss our famous signature thin-crust pizzas.

Join us for a dining experience that delights the senses and nourishes the soul.

We are under the supervision of the OK Kosher - Dairy - Chalav Yisrael

Experience culinary excellence with every bite in a welcoming atmosphere that celebrates the richness of kosher cuisine.

Click on the image to see OK Kosher certificate

Our Top Served Dishes

Explore a curated selection of our most popular and delicious offerings. From classic comforts to innovative creations, each dish promises a memorable culinary experience. Indulge in the best of our kosher cuisine, where every bite is a delight.

Fresh Homemade Pasta

At The Bay Cafe we strive to bring you the freshest gourmet homemade dishes.

You deserve for us to go the extra mile just for you! 

Lemon Curd Masacrpone Cheesecake in a Cup

One of our top selling desserts and guest’s favorite. This lemon curd is always made from scratch using the freshest and most wholesome ingredients. Our lemon curd is the perfect balance of sweet and tart. Guaranteed to put a smile on your face with every spoonful.
Jacob B
Jacob B
Everything was great! The location is really nice, the food was delicious and the service was good.
Steven A
Steven A
Best gnocchi in town
Shea Werner
Shea Werner
Very nice place, great service
Leeroy Jenkins
Leeroy Jenkins
Came for Valentine's dinner. Got amazing fettuccine that was made in back. Got a dessert to go. Highly recommend.
Miles Davis
Miles Davis
Booked a party for 50 people and was super impressed by the follow up to my initial call and planning of the event. Larissa is very responsive and thorough with follow up and planning. Upon arrival to our booking there were more guests than we reserved and the establishment and staff were quick to setup and add space for the additional guests all done so calmly not making it seem like it was an issue. Larissa, the owner and the chef were present and attentive and accommodated adding more dishes to the menu off the pre fixed menu. The food came out fresh, hot and quick at one time serving all guests at one for each course. There’s was bo favorite dish it was all amazing and delicious but the Pão de queijo is a must have. The glazed salmon was so fresh the freshest most moist tender salmon I’ve ever had. I can go in and on with the deserts, churros and cheesecake hit the spot. Service was phenomenal, Courteous patient and knowledgeable staff. Plan your event here, you’ll just add another 5 star review!

We offer on and off Catering for all occasions

Elevate your event with our catering service.

From intimate gatherings to grand celebrations, we ensure a flawless culinary experience. Trust us to delight your guests with exceptional dishes. Make your event a culinary success!

Opening Hour

It's Wednesday 5:24 PMWe're open

Better yet, see us in person!

We love our customers, so feel free to visit during normal business hours.

Reserve a Table

Click here to reserve a table now at our restaurant.

Better yet, see us in person!

Contact us

We are located at 2 Neptune Ave - Brooklyn NY 11235

Our team is here to help with any inquiries. Whether it’s dining in, catering, or more information, we’re just a message or call away. Get in touch now for a seamless experience.