Best Italian Food in Manhattan Beach, Brooklyn, NY

Casual All-Day Brunch Just Steps From The Shore

Order Online

Try our most popular items

View Full Menu

Mozzarella Sticks

Breaded & Seasoned Mozzarella Fried Golden served w/ Marinara Sauce

Add Item

Tiradito De Tuna

Add Item

Crispy Halloumi Salad

Mixed Greens, Romaine, Cherry Tomatoes, Cucumber, Mushroom and Caramelized Onions.

Add Item

PORCINI MUSHROOM SEA BASS

This amazing Wild Catch Chilean Sea Bass is perfectly buttery and delicious. It is served with mediterranean salsa verde on top. Comes with Organic Wild Rice and Grilled Vegetables.

Add Item

Hot chocolate

A warming and comforting cup of our decadent hot chocolate

Add Item

Welcome To The Bay Café

The Bay Cafe offers fresh, seasonal gourmet dishes crafted by talented trained chefs. Located across from the Bay, we serve lunch, dinner, and Sunday brunch. Enjoy signature thin-crust pizzas, gourmet pastas, and fresh fish in a warm, welcoming setting—perfect for families, dates, and everything in between. Join us for a dining experience that delights the senses and nourishes the soul.

Crave The Experience

Bold flavors. Beautiful plating. Every bite is designed to pull you in and keep you curious. From sunrise bites to late afternoon fuel-ups, The Bay Café serves more than just food — it’s a vibe you’ll want to come back for. From the first bite to the last, the food speaks for itself.

Explore Our Menu

Fresh Homemade Pasta, Crafted Just For You

Our homemade pasta is crafted with the finest ingredients and prepared fresh, every time. At The Bay Café, we strive to bring you the freshest gourmet homemade dishes. We believe in going the extra mile to deliver dishes that are bursting with flavor, just for you.

Lemon Curd Masacrpone Cheesecake In A Cup

One of our top selling desserts and guest’s favorite. This lemon curd is always made from scratch using the freshest and most wholesome ingredients. Our lemon curd is the perfect balance of sweet and tart. Guaranteed to put a smile on your face with every spoonful.

Order From Our Website

Your favorites are just a few clicks away. Browse the full menu, customize your order, and enjoy the same café vibe at home, at the office, or wherever your day takes you. Fresh, fast, and just how you like it.

Order Now

📸A Taste of The Bay

Get a glimpse of the bold, beautiful dishes that define The Bay Café. Fresh, flavorful, and always photo-worthy.

Catering For All Occasions

We offer on and off Catering for all occasions. Elevate your event with our catering service. From intimate gatherings to grand celebrations, we ensure a flawless culinary experience. Trust us to delight your guests with exceptional dishes. Make your event a culinary success!

Got Plans? Reserve Your Spot Now!

Looking for a cozy table with a view or planning a chill meetup by the beach? Secure your seat now and skip the wait. Whether it’s brunch with friends or a casual date, we’ve got the perfect spot waiting for you.

Book Your Table

Events At The Bay Café

From intimate dinners and birthday celebrations to business meetings and special occasions, The Bay Café offers a cozy, elegant setting designed for memorable gatherings. Our experienced chefs and staff customize every event with gourmet menu options tailored to your needs

Plan With Us

We are under the supervision of the OK Kosher

We proudly operate under the supervision of OK Kosher - Dairy - Chalav Yisrael. Enjoy culinary excellence in a warm and welcoming atmosphere, where every bite reflects the richness of kosher cuisine.

What our guests are saying

Check out our most recent reviews!

Wonderful Experience at The Bay Cafe! We had such a great time at The Bay Cafe. The food was excellent — we ordered the Turbot fish and the Caprese, and both were absolutely amazing. The Caprese, in particular, was so fresh and flavorful. Everything came out quickly, and the service was fantastic — super friendly and attentive without being overbearing. And the view of the water just made the whole experience even more relaxing and special. Can’t wait to come back!

Albert M.

If you’re looking for a hidden gem with an unbeatable combination of excellent service, delicious food, and great prices, look no further than Bay Café by. This spot truly excels in offering high-quality kosher dishes.

Moshe A.

The only place to celebrate every milestone and every day moments! From the food to the incredible service, the Bay Cafe is a hidden gem. Louis, our server, has been an incredible part of our experience for years.